Difference between revisions of "Attributes"

Revision as of 21:57, 11 August 2011

Attributes in Diablo III consist of Attack, Precision, Vitality, and Defense. Each attribute affects a single property in Diablo III. See the respective character class pages for Barbarian, Witch Doctor, Wizard, Monk, and the Demon Hunter for more specific details.

Although attributes are automatically-placed in Diablo III, passive skills and the ability to socket very high level gems should allow for as much or more character variety as was possible in Diablo II, where attributes could be placed wherever a player desired.

Core Attributes

The core attributes changed in December of 2010. This is the current list:

Attributes in the UI from d.163.com, during a 2011 press event.

Attack

Attack governs how much damage a character does in all attacks, physical and magical.
Each point of Attack gives:

• +x% Damage Bonus (based on class)

Precision

Precision governs the chance that a character will make a critical hit in all attacks, physical and magical.
Each point of Precision gives:

• +x% Critical Strike Chance (based on class)

Defense

Defense governs the amount of damage a character takes from all attacks, physical and magical.
Each point of Defense gives:

• +x Damage Reduction (based on class)

Vitality

Vitality governs the amount of life a character has.
Each point of Vitality gives:

• +x Life (based on class)

Willpower

Willpower was formally the fifth attribute, but it has been taken out of the game at some point in 2011. The likelihood of it working with every different resource system was probably not so good. The stat's description remains below:

Willpower governed the amount of resource a character has.
Each point of Willpower gave:

• Varies greatly bases on each class and its specific resource.

Core Attribute Changes

The core attributes have undergone significant changes since conception. Originally, each attribute affected more character properties in Diablo III than in D1 or D2. This was part of the D3 Team's design goal; to make all of the attributes useful to all of the classes. On December 20, 2010, that changed when D3 Community Manager Bashiok made an announcement[1]on the Battle.net forums of the new attribute system in which each core attribute affects a single property.

This change wasn't as controversial as the pre-set attribute announcement, but Bashiok's post did generate a lively 26-page debatein the forums. Bashiok made several points in favor of the change, and several less-favorable points were made in the forum. The debate is distilled here:

Pros

• None of the old attributes helped control resource management.

• Easier to make all attributes valuable to all classes.

• Before, in some cases it was not obvious what attribute affected a particular skill.

• Makes core attributes simple and straightforward to understand.

• Makes game balance easier.

• Makes valuing item stats easier.

Cons

• It wasn't that confusing, especially with pre-set attributes.

• Feels like a dumbing-down of the game.

• Having all attributes equally valuable to all classes is not always beneficial.

• No character has a primary attribute.

• The attribute names are uninspiring.

Old Attribute System

See the respective pages on Strength, Dexterity, Vitality, and Willpower (renamed from Energy in D2) to see what attributes originally looked like.

No Customizable Attributes

The biggest change about attributes in Diablo III is that they will no longer be player-assigned on level up. This means that two "naked" characters of the same class and of the same level will have the exact same attack, precision, vitality, defense, and willpower, as well as the same hit points, resource value, damage, and etc. Except that they won't, since differences in their skills, skillrunes, and traits, not to mention equipment, including charms/talisman, will make them very different.

Though this seems a settled issue as of late 2010, it was highly-controversial when it was first revealed, back in late 2009. Jay Wilson explained it, as best he could in those days long before charms, the talisman, gems, or traits had been revealed. [2]

Jay Wilson: Stat progression as a system is very difficult for a lot of players to understand because you get these 5 points, but you don’t exactly know where to put them or what benefit you’re getting with them. You might make some obvious choices, for example, with Diablo II’s Sorceress, you might put all of your points into energy because that’s the obvious choice, right? Except that for almost every build out there, you’ve just made the wrong choice. Any system where you have to go up onto the Internet to figure out what the right answer is, is not a good customization system. Any system where there’s a “right” answer is not a good system for customization. The truth is, with stat point systems, they are simple math. It’s not hard to figure out what the absolute best choice is so we decided we didn’t want that as a customization system.

With that being said, we do have another system we’re working on. The specific intent of it is to capture the imagination of what stat point spending was supposed to do, which is, “I want to be stronger. I want to be tougher.” These kind of simple ideas are not contextualized well within a skill system. The skill system is about what the player is doing, not higher ideals about what their character is. So, we’re going to work on a system that really satisfies that feeling, but is way easier to understand and also has some true customization to it.

Pre-Set Attribute Argument

Much digital ink has been spilled on this issue, since it was revealed at Blizzcon, in October 2008. (The first word came from an interview by Diii.net, and immediately resulted in a 30-page forumthread.) Some portion of that hew and cry was spurred by an initial misunderstanding; reporters assumed items would still have strength, dexterity, and other attribute requirements (they do not), but even with that issue clarified shortly after, the topic of pre-set attributes has remained a contentious one.

There are a variety of arguments on each side of the issue. The debate was nicely encapsulated in an On the Drawing Board column about pre-set attributes, from which the following bullet points are taken: [3]

Pros

• Manual setting is no longer needed, as there are no stat requirements on items any more.

• It's beginner friendly. New players won't ruin their characters with poor stat allocation.

• Attributes were largely irrelevant in D2, since all characters with the same build used identical equipment and stat allocation. Typical D2 guide advice, "Enough strength for your heaviest item, then all the rest into vitality."

• Enables easier/better game balancing for the developers, since they can know about how powerful characters will be.

• Prevents twinking and other exploits by low level characters.

• World of Warcraft uses auto-attributes, and it's the most popular RPG ever.

• No need for attribute respecs, which would otherwise have to be incorporated since skill respecs will be.

• It boosts the importance of items, since those and skills are what differentiates characters.

• High level characters can use the items they find, since they won't, for example, be built with far too little strength for that cool new item they just found.

• It respects traditional RPG philosophy of archetype characters in the sense of how a physical and mental ability of a class is supposed to be depending on its role. A Barbarian with very high Willpower or a Wizard with too much Strength really makes no sense from roleplaying perspective in a fantasy game.

• It completely eliminates situations when people find a better items with more points in stat X and realize that they have one or more unnecessary invested points right now in stat X just because of these new items and those points could be relocated in other stat for better purpose. Maybe later on they will need those permanently invested points in stat X, but not right now. The problem is that it will never end, until they will find all items perfect and reroll their characters.

• Rerolling is fun but rerolling because of messed stats is not fun.

Cons

• Reduced Character Variety. Unusual and non-cookie cutter builds need to allocate their attributes differently.

• We won’t be noobs forever. Why gimp a major aspect of game play individuality when it won't be necessary once gamers have some experience?

• No Attributes = No skill required. If players want to mainline strength and ignore vitality because they're good enough to survive with fewer hit points, or vice versa so they can play with a weaker, specialized build, why take away that option?

• Rerolling is fun. Making new characters is a hallmark of the Diablo series. This isn't WoW where one high level character takes months to build, and then lasts forever with respecs.

• What about hardcore? HC chars want/need to be built very differently than SC, since death is forever.

Blizzard's Response

The D3 Team never issued a formal, multi-point rebuttal, but they have commented on this issue a few times, being careful not to give away their plans for stat customization via systems, such as gems, traits, and the talisman, that they weren't yet ready to reveal.

Jay Wilson: For the most part attribute spending in Diablo II was a great way, when you didn’t know how to play the game, to break your character. Most people didn’t know where to put them and when they found out the answer was always kind of weird like "Put 5 points in Energy and then all the rest of the points in Vitality." [4]

The longest comment came from D3 Community Manager Bashiok who offered a detailed argument in a forum post in December 2008. [5]

Loss of character customization:

With the current skill system, runes, and item affixes, as well as other unmentionables, there’s not going to be any issue with not having enough customization. If there is, bottom line, we’ll add more. We’re not going to release a game we’re not happy with, and a lack of character customization options would make us unhappy. But, even right now we have a lot more variety and ability to customize a character than Diablo II had.

Odd character builds:

Similarly is being able to create “off-spec” builds, or characters that aren’t just cookie cutter ideals of the class you’re playing. This is important to the game, and we will ensure that it doesn't get "tuned out" of the game. ...Manual attributes were not what made them possible in Diablo II. The ability to make these types of characters relies solely on the complexity and diversity of the the options available to steer your character, and not that they come in the form of a "+" button.

Less feeling of level up achievement:

The loss of a feeling of a leveling achievement is actually something we recognize and intend to address.

We've always assigned our own points in Diablo games:

The nostalgia of simply having points, and spending them on base stats is probably the most difficult. Liking something because it’s familiar is difficult to argue with, but it’s also probably the easiest to overcome. Since we can’t force your memories out of you, we just have to make the best game we can and hope you realize that manual attribute assignment isn’t the best, most engaging or entertaining form of character customization possible, and that we’re offering an even deeper and richer game without those buttons.

Attributes in the Character Sheet

Character sheet from BlizzCon 2010

The character sheet in Diablo III is similar to that found in Diablo II. While the character sheet shown displays the attributes prior to the attribute change, the interface itself isn't likely to change much before beta or release.

Since the attributes have no secondary effects, the character sheet is likely to look a bit bare, but hopes are high that at the very least the Lying Character Screen won't return. It wasn't exactly a popular feature in Diablo II.

Kind of similar to Diablo II, as well, are the two panes below the attributes and resistance icons which list precisely what effect the player is gaining from their attributes and item modifiers, pulling data not only from the attributes but also from the items worn, and likely as well, the traits selected by the player.